The Indie Facts of Life
Last week’s article “Appraising The Strategic Value of Airplay For Indie Artists,” featuring Tom Baldrica, generated a number of heated responses. One person who has been connected with Indie careers and was especially passionate about the challenges outlined in the article had a lot to say, but wished to do so anonymously. We agreed, let’s call him Mr. X.
Baldrica cautioned, “You’re out of your mind to play the national chart game as an independent.” Mr. X agrees. “Baldrica sure pulled the curtains back on this subject. The country music economy is probably a Top 15 or Top 10 marketplace. When you get to those numbers you might start to see sales. It goes back to something I heard Joe Galante say on some panel a while ago. Talking to an artist he said, ‘I can take you to the audience, but I can’t make the audience take you.’ I can’t think of a better line to describe what happens. Between nowhere and No. 25 there’s not a lot of difference on the monitored chart. I’ve had promoters get us to No. 45 and say ‘congratulations.’ But realistically, congratulations on what? The record wasn’t played in morning drive or mid-day, in fact it was completely invisible. So tons of money later there’s little to show.”
But Mr. X is a bit stoic about the fight to break an indie artist. “You know what? Knowing the chart facts of life isn’t likely to keep most people from doing anything any differently,” X says. “The allure of the Nashville dream is so bright and blinding, you could write this article and pin it on every door in America, but there still will be another crop of people coming to Nashville saying, ‘I’m different. It only applies to all those people that weren’t good enough’.”
In last week’s article Baldrica also suggested that independents might be better served working toward a regional approach. But Mr. X takes exception to this idea. “The problem is while it sounds good to build a story regionally, it’s actually used against you and it then becomes impossible to break out nationally. For example great acts that were branded regional such as Jack Ingram, Pat Green and Cross Canadian Ragweed. This is a major label game and that’s a fact. As an industry we need to admit it’s far more label focused than artist, or song focused. If it was based on the song, then you would have more acts in the Top 20 actually selling records. The inherent monopoly of the majors makes it easy for them to chart a Top 20, even if it has almost no relation to audience acceptance. Miranda Lambert sold over a million units before she ever had a Top 15, which means the chart didn’t reflect her audience acceptance. While the chart does launch more careers than any other vehicle, the monopoly of the majors allows for a lot of misses, too.”
And indies also get shut out of a lot of exposure opportunities according to Mr. X. “The majors dug this pond and we’re just asking to fish in it. But they own the fishing rights and as an independent you are relegated to the corners of the pond. Rarely, you might pull in a big fish, but mostly you are just net casting for minnows. We’re trying to say, ‘Our music is good enough to be a part of the system,’ but it’s not our pond. You can’t believe the leverage the majors have. Opportunities for valuable added exposure from vehicles such as Award shows or duets with artists on major labels, for example, are completely shut out for us. I don’t want to sound bitter, but these are just the facts. If there is any frustration in my voice it is the romance they put around a great song, and not near enough emphasis on the leverage of the label which is the reality of the actual forces needed to get to the starting line.”
- Crested Butte Songwriters Festival Debuts - November 28, 2011
- Scott Borchetta On CNBC Power Lunch - November 22, 2011
- Twitter Used To Rank Republican Candidates - November 21, 2011
Thunder 102 is in a small market, but we’re only an hour and a half outside New York City and 10 minutes from Bethel Woods, the original site of Woodstock. Our listeners have the opportunity to experience the “Majors” at Bethel Woods and to meet them when we have the opportunity for interviews…on air or at the venue. Recently we dedicated a portion of our playlist to “Independent” artists. This has been a real “win/win”. Our listeners have responded very well to the “new” artists and consider it a special experience to hear them interviewed on air, and to meet them at station events. From Amber Hayes, David Adam Byrns, Jake McVey, Gwen Sebastian, The Roys, Sherry Lynn, Iron Cowboy, Somerville and Alyssa Startup and Cooper Boone there is indeed a true crop of talent in the independent ranks. We’re trying to do our part and we wish them all the best!
I applaud Paul and Thunder 102 for giving Independents a chance and such great exposure. We need more of those opportunities. Thank you Paul, from all of our Indie clients, past, present and future!
I can personally say Paul is true to his word and goes out of his way for up ‘n coming country music artists like myself! I’ve been privileged to do a live interview with Paul and his morning crew. Everyone at Thunder 102 is amazing and I will never forget their support!
I could not agree more with Abby and Riley! Paul Ciliberto and his Staff at Thunder 102 have been incredibly supportive of Iron Cowboy and our music. Aside from playing our music on the air, Thunder 102 has provided us with the opportunity to work with other Indie artists as well as some major acts. We can’t thank Paul and Thunder 102 enough for their support, and I challenge other stations across the country to take a gamble on some independent “up and coming” artists……You may be surprised at the results!